League Championship Series Winner
1 win
1994
Seattle Pilots Achievements
Championships and individual honors across Paul O'Neill’s DBL career.
Championships & postseason
Title seasons and postseason series won with the player’s team.
1994
Seattle Pilots Division Series Winner
3 wins
1994
Seattle Pilots 
1991
Kansas City Royals 
1988
Cincinnati Reds Individual honors
Awards grouped by type, with every recorded season and team shown below.
Season awards
Major individual honors earned across the career.
| Honor | Season / team |
|---|---|
| World Series MVP 1× |
1988
Cincinnati Reds
|
All-Star selections
The seasons this player was selected as an All-Star.
| Honor | Season / team |
|---|---|
| All-Star 1× |
1987
Cincinnati Reds
|
In-season honors
Weekly and monthly awards, with the team represented at the time.
| Honor | Season / team |
|---|---|
| Player of the Week 5× |
1996 · June · Week 3
Seattle Pilots
1988 · May · Week 23
Cincinnati Reds
1987 · September · Week 7
Cincinnati Reds
1987 · April · Week 20
Cincinnati Reds
1985 · July · Week 1
New York Yankees
|
Division and Championship Series wins are credited when OOTP records a postseason appearance for the player with the winning team. Players who did not appear in a postseason game may not be included.